Question: Why should we trust the Bible as God’s revelation?
The Christian case for trusting the Bible centers on Jesus Christ. The writings present testimony about His life, teaching, death, and resurrection. They also show Him receiving Israel’s Scriptures as God’s authoritative word and commissioning witnesses to teach in His name.
These connections give us reasons to trust Scripture. Understanding those reasons requires examining the testimony, considering Christ’s authority, and asking which writings faithfully convey the revelation God entrusted to His prophets and apostles.
Christians also confess that recognizing God’s Word depends on the Holy Spirit. Evidence matters, but our ability to investigate does not make us independent of God’s help.
Why This Matters
Our previous inquiry used Scripture to explain how God makes Himself known. That raises a necessary question: Why receive these particular writings as His word?
Perhaps we grew up trusting the Bible. Perhaps someone told us it was full of mistakes. Neither familiarity nor suspicion settles the question.
Trust deserves reasons. We need to understand what the Bible claims, what supports those claims, and what conclusions the evidence can reasonably bear.
This essay develops an introductory case. Questions about individual books, manuscript differences, and particular objections will require closer examination as we proceed.
What Do We Mean by Revelation, Inspiration, and Authority?
Revelation is God making Himself and His truth known. Inspiration describes God’s work through human writers so that their writings communicate His word. Authority concerns Scripture’s rightful claim on what we believe and how we live. The canon is the recognized collection of biblical books.
These terms concern related but distinct questions. A document might preserve an accurate account of an event without possessing divine authority. Establishing that something happened and establishing that God speaks through a particular writing are connected tasks, but they are not identical.
What Does Scripture Claim About Itself?
Paul reminds Timothy that the sacred writings can make him wise for salvation through faith in Christ. He then describes Scripture as “breathed out by God” and explains its usefulness for teaching, correction, and training (2 Timothy 3:14–17).
The claim concerns both source and purpose. Scripture comes from God and equips His people to believe and live faithfully.
Peter likewise describes prophecy as coming through people carried along by the Holy Spirit (2 Peter 1:19–21). Human writers were involved, but their message did not originate in human will alone.
These passages tell us what Scripture claims. They do not independently establish that the claim is true or identify every book that belongs in the Bible.
Still, a writing’s testimony about itself matters. Before evaluating a claim, we must understand it. The Bible presents itself as more than a collection of human reflections about God.
Can We Examine the Bible Without First Assuming It Is Inspired?
Yes. We can consider biblical writings as historical documents before reaching a conclusion about their divine authority.
The Bible contains multiple writings, produced by different authors in different circumstances. Their collection into one volume does not erase their individual character or make every account an independent witness.
We can ask ordinary historical questions: What does this writer claim? How did the writer obtain the information? What sources were available? Where do accounts agree or differ? What other evidence helps us assess them?
Luke, for example, refers to earlier accounts, testimony passed down by eyewitnesses, and his own careful investigation (Luke 1:1–4). This establishes his stated method and purpose. Evaluating his success requires examining his account.
Taking that approach avoids a simple circular argument: “The Bible is inspired because the Bible says so.” We begin by considering testimony and its credibility. We then ask what that testimony gives us reason to believe about Jesus and His authority.
A Closer Example: Paul’s Resurrection Testimony
Paul’s discussion of the resurrection gives us something specific to examine.
He tells the Corinthians that he passed on a message he had received: Christ died, was buried, was raised, and appeared to witnesses. He names Cephas, James, and the apostles, mentions a large group, and includes himself among those to whom Christ appeared (1 Corinthians 15:3–11).
In another letter, Paul reports spending fifteen days with Cephas—Peter—and meeting James, the Lord’s brother (Galatians 1:18–19). His account places him in personal contact with people he identifies as resurrection witnesses. That gives his testimony a connection to the people concerned, rather than leaving him dependent only on an anonymous chain of reports.
What does this support?
At minimum, Paul’s letters provide testimony that resurrection appearances belonged to the message he received and preached. He also claims personal experience and contact with other named witnesses.
What does it not establish by itself?
Paul’s list is not five hundred separate surviving statements. His report that many witnesses remained alive does not show that every reader interviewed them. Nor does naming witnesses automatically prove their account.
Nevertheless, this is substantive testimony requiring an explanation. A claim that the resurrection message arose only after all contact with the original witnesses had disappeared must reckon with Paul’s reported connections.
We must then compare explanations. Did the witnesses encounter the risen Jesus? Were they mistaken? Did some other process produce their convictions? A serious alternative must explain the relevant testimony, not merely announce that miracles cannot happen.
The Christian conclusion is that Jesus rose bodily from the dead. Establishing that conclusion fully requires a broader examination than these paragraphs provide. Here, we have identified a concrete reason to investigate the resurrection as a historical claim rather than dismiss it as an undefined religious symbol.
Paul himself makes its importance unmistakable: without Christ’s resurrection, Christian faith fails (1 Corinthians 15:14–19).
How Does Jesus Lead Us Toward Trust in Scripture?
Historical testimony about Jesus matters because of the person it presents.
If God raised Jesus from the dead, that would give powerful support to His identity and mission. We would have reason to take His teaching about God and Scripture with corresponding seriousness. This is the central connection in the Christian argument.
In John’s Gospel, Jesus says that “Scripture cannot be broken” (John 10:35). Within His argument, Scripture possesses an authority His opponents must reckon with.
The same pattern appears elsewhere. Jesus appeals to Scripture as grounds for obedience during temptation and explains His mission through the Law of Moses, the Prophets, and the Psalms (Matthew 4:1–11; Luke 24:25–27, 44–47).
The argument therefore has a sequence: examine the testimony about Jesus, consider the grounds for receiving His authority, and take seriously His treatment of Scripture.
This provides a reason for Christian trust rooted in Christ. It also leaves a further question: How does His authority relate to the writings produced after His earthly ministry?
Why Receive the Apostolic Writings?
Jesus did more than leave people to remember Him as best they could.
In John’s Gospel, He promises His disciples the Holy Spirit’s help in remembering His teaching and bearing witness to Him (John 14:25–26; John 15:26–27). These promises concern their particular role as His witnesses. They do not guarantee that every later Christian teacher will speak without error.
The New Testament also contains evidence of apostolic writings being received as Scripture. Second Peter discusses Paul’s letters alongside “the other Scriptures” (2 Peter 3:15–16). This supports the connection between apostolic teaching and written Scripture, although it does not supply a complete list of New Testament books.
The Christian case thus connects the earlier Scriptures Jesus received with the witness He commissioned.
Identifying the writings that faithfully preserve that witness requires examining particular books. Not every New Testament writer belonged to the original Twelve, and a claim of apostolic connection must be tested.
Within the Protestant understanding followed here, the church recognizes the authority of these writings; it does not create that authority. Disagreements among Protestant, Catholic, and Orthodox churches about parts of the Old Testament collection deserve their own examination.
Does Trust Require Ignoring Difficulties?
No. Several questions need to remain distinct:
- Preservation: How closely do surviving copies preserve what was written?
- Translation: How accurately does a translation express the underlying text?
- History: Did the reported events happen?
- Interpretation: Have we understood the writer’s meaning?
- Authority: Does the writing speak for God?
Evidence answering one question does not automatically answer the others. A carefully copied falsehood remains false. A trustworthy text can still be misunderstood.
Apparent contradictions also require careful attention. We should consider context, literary form, wording, and what each author actually claims. Showing that two accounts could fit together answers a different question from demonstrating exactly how the events unfolded.
Honest confidence leaves room to say, “I do not yet understand this passage.” It also requires us to examine a proposed solution rather than accept it simply because it protects our preferred conclusion.
What Place Does the Holy Spirit Have?
If Scripture is God’s Word, its authority comes from Him. Our agreement recognizes that authority; it does not confer it.
John Calvin described Scripture’s words as being “sealed by the inward testimony of the Spirit.” In Institutes of the Christian Religion, 1.7.4–5, he argues that the Spirit brings the settled conviction that God is Scripture’s author. Human arguments can serve an important purpose, but they cannot manufacture that conviction.
This does not make evidence irrelevant. It explains why Christian confidence involves more than our skill in evaluating arguments.
Nor should the Spirit’s testimony be reduced to a powerful feeling. People can feel certain about conflicting beliefs. We must continue testing our interpretations and distinguishing God’s Word from our own impressions.
We can pray for understanding while examining the evidence carefully. Both activities acknowledge our need to learn.
Key Takeaways from This Essay
- Scripture claims to communicate God’s word through human writers.
- We can examine biblical writings as historical sources without first assuming their inspiration.
- Paul’s testimony gives the resurrection message identifiable connections to people who claimed to witness the risen Jesus.
- The Christian case connects Jesus’ authority with the Scriptures He received and the witnesses He commissioned.
- Recognizing particular biblical books requires examining their relationship to that prophetic and apostolic revelation.
- Preservation, historical credibility, interpretation, and divine authority are related questions that require distinct answers.
- The Holy Spirit enables recognition of God’s Word; our recognition does not give it authority.
Key Questions to Consider
- What is the difference between a writing’s claim to speak for God and the reasons for accepting that claim?
- What does Paul’s resurrection testimony establish, and what further questions must we examine?
- How does trust in Jesus connect with trust in Scripture?
- Why does accurate preservation alone fail to establish divine authority?
- Am I willing to examine both an objection to the Bible and the answer offered in its defense?
Field Note
Read 1 Corinthians 15:3–11. Make three brief notes: What does Paul report? What reasons does this passage give for taking his testimony seriously? What would you still need to investigate?
Ask God for understanding and the willingness to follow what is true. Careful inquiry is one way we take seriously the claim that He has spoken.
Next Step
1.4 How Do We Understand and Apply the Bible Faithfully?
Trusting Scripture brings responsibility. We must learn to read its words in context, recognize what each writer intends, and apply its teaching faithfully. Our next inquiry considers how to move from reading a passage to understanding and living what it teaches.